Table 1

Agreement About the Psychiatric Diagnosis Between Treating Practitioners and Experts*

DiagnosisAgreeDisagreeKappa95% CI
PresentAbsent
Acquired brain injuries1711890.7540.590–0.910
Schizophrenia-spectrum psychosis8046180.7360.573–0.898
Substance-induced psychotic disorders213480.3080.154–0.461
Depressive disorders18112140.6620.449–0.824
Anxiety disorders1132110.114−0.0487–0.2769
Substance abuse or dependence4868280.6070.447–0.767
Intellectual disabilities513901
Personality disorders613801
Principal axis I diagnosis10115280.4040.283–0.560
Any psychosis8837190.6990.536–0.851
  • * Comprising 57 experts engaged by the prosecution and 87 experts engaged by the defense.

  • Diagnoses include mania, delirium tremens, psychotic depression, schizophrenia-spectrum psychosis, and SIPD.