Professional uncertainty and the problem of supplier-induced demand

https://doi.org/10.1016/0277-9536(82)90234-9Get rights and content

Abstract

This paper discusses the puzzling problem of large differences in per capita use of certain common surgical procedures among neighboring populations, which by all available measures are quite similar in need for and access to services. The evidence reviewed here supports the hypothesis that variations occur to a large extent because of differences among physicians in their evaluation of patients (diagnosis) or in their belief in the value of the procedures for meeting patient needs (therapy). This hypothesis, which we call the professional uncertainty hypothesis, is germane to current controversies concerning the nature and extent of supplier influence on the demand for medical services. It is also important because of its implications for health regulatory policy. Our plan is to (1) review the relevance of the hypotheses for the supplier-induced demand controversy; (2) review the epidemiologic evidence on the nature and causes of variation; (3) examine patterns of use of common surgical procedures to illustrate the importance of supplier influence on utilization; and (4) consider some of the implications of the professional uncertainty hypotheses for public policy.

References (60)

  • M. Zubkoff et al.

    Hospital cost containment: selected notes for future policy

    (1978)
  • M. Zubkoff

    Health: a victim or cause of inflation?

    (1976)
  • K. Arrow

    Uncertainty and the welfare economies of medical care

    Am. Econ. Rev.

    (1963)
  • R.G. Evans

    Supplier-induced demand: some empirical evidence and implications

  • R. Evans et al.

    Moving the target to hit the bullet: generation of utilization by physicians in Canada

  • The economics of physician and patient behavior: National Bureau of Economic Research Conference

    J. Human Resour.

    (1978)
  • U.E. Reinhardt

    Comment

  • F.A. Sloan et al.

    Competition among physicians

  • M. Pauly

    The behavior of non-profit hospital monopolies: alternative models of the hospital

  • B.J. McNeil et al.

    Fallacy of the five-year survival in lung cancer

    New Engl. J. Med.

    (1978)
  • J.A. Glover

    The incidence of tonsillectomy in school children

    Proc. R. Soc. Med.

    (1938)
  • J.A. Glover

    Monthly bulletin of the Ministry of Health 9:62

  • J.P. Bunker

    Surgical manpower: a comparison of operations and surgeons in the United States and in England and Wales

    New Engl. J. Med.

    (1970)
  • J.E. Wennberg et al.

    Small area variations in health care delivery

    Science

    (1973)
  • J.E. Wennberg et al.

    Health care delivery in Maine I: patterns of use of common surgical procedures

    J. Maine Med.

    (1975)
    J.E. Wennberg et al.

    Health care delivery in Maine I: patterns of use of common surgical procedures

    J. Maine Med. Ass.

    (1975)
  • D.E. Detmer et al.

    Regional differences in surgical care based upon uniform physician and hospital discharge abstract data

    Annls. Surg.

    (1978)
  • N.P. Roos et al.

    Elective surgical rates: do high rates mean lower standards?

    New Engl. J. Med.

    (1977)
  • H. Stockwell et al.

    Variations in surgery in Ontario

    Med. Care

    (1979)
  • C.E. Lewis

    Variations in the incidence of surgery

    New Engl. J. Med.

    (1969)
  • H.S. Luft

    How do health-maintenance organizations achieve their saving?

    New Engl. J. Med.

    (1978)
  • McPherson K., Clifford P., Wennberg J. and Hovind O. Small area variations in use of surgery: an international...
  • A. Gittelsohn et al.

    On the incidence of tonsillectomy and other common surgical procedures

  • J.E. Wennberg et al.

    Small area variations in health care delivery

    Science

    (1973)
  • J.E. Wennberg et al.

    A test of consumer contributions to small area variations in health care delivery

    J. Maine Med. Ass.

    (1977)
  • J.E. Wennberg et al.

    Small area variations in health care delivery

    Science

    (1973)
  • M.S. Feldstein

    Hospital cost inflation: a study of non-profit price dynamics

    Am. Econ. Rev.

    (1971)
  • J.P. Bunker

    Surgical manpower: a comparison of operations and surgeons in the United States and in England and Wales

    New Engl. J. Med.

    (1970)
  • E. Vayda et al.

    Comparison of provincial surgical rates in 1968

    Can. J. Surg.

    (1968)
  • C.E. Lewis

    Variations in the incidence of surgery

    New Engl. J. Med.

    (1969)
  • Cited by (447)

    • Indirectness (transferability) is critical when considering existing economic evaluations for GRADE clinical practice guidelines: a systematic review

      2022, Journal of Clinical Epidemiology
      Citation Excerpt :

      Provider and decision maker acceptability in the decision context also weighs into the ability of an economic evaluation to remain useful in another context—gathering of such information may rely largely on information gathered from outside of the economic evaluation itself through panel members, literature queries, or external stakeholder consultation. It has long been understood that healthcare providers carry inherent and variable assumptions of disease and values they place on alternative interventions [80]. As well, willingness-to-pay thresholds would need to be comparable as an intervention may be cost-effective in one setting and not in another solely based on the differences in the decision maker threshold [39,57].

    • Use of electroconvulsive therapy for individuals receiving inpatient psychiatric care on a nationwide scale in France: Variations linked to health care supply

      2022, Brain Stimulation
      Citation Excerpt :

      Several explanatory hypotheses can be drawn from the literature on unwarranted medical practice variations, which represent the gap between practice and evidence-based medicine. One of these hypotheses is the difference in preferences or habits of health care providers, in particular in a context of uncertainty [12]. For ECT, this can notably be linked to the high efficacy of the procedure, as opposed to the negative representations among some health professionals [13,14], which is in line with the common depictions in the general population [15–17], and to the continuum of clinical manifestations of mental disorders, which can make it difficult to determine the ideal timing of the procedure among a sequence of alternatives [18].

    View all citing articles on Scopus

    This work was supported by research grant No. 18-P-97192 from the Health Care Financing Administration. The authors wish to acknowledge the able research and editorial assistance of Lynn Anderholm in preparation of this manuscript.

    View full text