Sexual sadism in sexual offenders: An elusive diagnosis
Introduction
The first recorded case of a sadistic sexual offender appears to have been Gilles de Rais, a 15th century French nobleman (Hickey, 1991). He was said to have raped, tortured, and murdered hundreds of children. Reports over the centuries since that time reveal individual sexual offenders who display apparently sadistic features, including, of course, Donatien Alphonse Francois, the Comte de Sade, after whom the disorder was named (Hickey, 1991). However, it was not until Professor Richard von Krafft-Ebing (1886) wrote his comprehensive descriptions of sexual deviancy that sadism was accepted as topic for scientific study. Stekel's (1929) later book on sadism and masochism provided clear descriptions of the features of these two related disorders and this finally led to the popularization of the use of these terms in clinical practice. While there clearly are sadists who do not sexually offend, Breslow, 1989, Spengler, 1977, Weinberg, 1987, and who are of scientific and clinical interest in their own right, it is only those sadists who commit sexual crimes that are the focus of this paper.
There is now a very extensive literature on sadistic sexual offenders including numerous case reports Arieti & Schreiber, 1981, Guttmacher, 1963, Kozel et al., 1966, Rae, 1967, Schechter, 1990, Schlesinger, 1990 as well as reviews and research studies Brittain, 1970, Grubin, 1994a, Hickey, 1991, Holmes & DeBurger, 1988, Ressler et al., 1988, Revitch, 1957, Warren et al., 1996. Much of this literature also deals with sexual murderers, not all of whom are necessarily sadists (Grubin, 1994a), and serial murderers, not all of whom are sexual murderers (Ressler et al., 1988). Many studies, unfortunately, do not satisfactorily discriminate among these possibly different types of offenders, and some authors assume that serial killers are in fact serial sexual murderers (Myers, Reccoppa, Burton, & McElroy, 1993), while others conclude that serial sexual murderers are sadists (Giannangelo, 1996). This confused use of various terms makes it difficult to review this extensive literature and at times in this paper we will be obliged to drew inferences from studies that have not made these distinctions as clearly as we would like.
What we will attempt to do is first consider conceptual definitional issues, including diagnostic criteria, and then examine the operational bases on which the diagnosis of sexual sadism is made. Finally, we will draw implications for research and practice that we believe derive from our consideration of the literature.
Section snippets
Definitional issues
As noted above, we intend to discuss only those sadists who commit sexual offenses although of course actual diagnoses of sexual sadism are the same whether applied to offenders or not. Before we consider the various definitions of sexual sadism that have appeared in the literature, however, we must distinguish some related terms.
Implications for research and practice
This review suggests that the elusive nature of sexual sadism is a function of the need to determine that sexual arousal is fused with some aspect of the offender's behavior or the victim's response. If the offender denies either having recurrent sadistic sexual fantasies, or being sexually aroused by enacting sadistic behaviors, then the researcher or diagnostician must infer such fusion of sexual arousal and sadistic acts from sources independent of the offender. Since sexual offenders are
Conclusions
In conclusion then, after more than 100 years of research and clinical observations we seem no closer to a satisfactory, agreed upon, and reliable diagnosis of sadism than was true when Krafft-Ebing (1886) first described a series of cases he called sadistic. Our review of the evidence does not encourage confidence that things will improve in the future, so we recommend abandoning the diagnosis. Instead, we suggest that researchers rely on behavioral data to identify their subjects along
References (128)
- et al.
Differential erection response patterns of sexual child abusers to stimuli describing activities with children
Behavior Therapy
(1984) - et al.
The evaluation and treatment of sexual violence, necrophilia, and asphyxiophilia
Psychiatric Clinics of North America
(1992) - et al.
Masturbatory reconditioning: an evaluative review
Advances in Behaviour Research and Therapy
(1991) - et al.
Phallometric testing with sexual offenders: limits to its value
Clinical Psychology Review
(2000) The native and dynamics of sexual homicide: an integrative review
Aggression and Violent Behavior: A Review Journal
(2000)- et al.
Psychopathology, biopsychosocial factors, crime characteristics, and classification of 25 homicidal youths
Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
(1995) The berserk syndrome: a review of mass murder
Aggression and Violent Behavior: A Review Journal
(1997)Paraphilias
- et al.
Co-morbidity of alcoholism and the paraphilias
Journal of Forensic Science
(1996) Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
(1980)
Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
Patterns of forcible rape
Probing the mind of a serial killer
Multiple murder of a schizophrenic patient: a dynamic interpretation
Journal of the American Academy of Psychoanalysis
Psychosocial correlates of suicidal behaviors in an urban population
Crisis
The reliability of the rape index in a sample of rapists and nonrapists
Violence and Victims
Sexual assault in society: the role of the juvenile offender
Comparisons between sexual and non-sexual rapist subtypes: sexual arousal to rape, offense precursors and offense characteristics
Criminal Justice and Behavior
Sequelae of sexual assault: the survivor's perspective
The antiandrogen and hormonal treatment of sex offenders
The heterogeneity/homogeneity of pedophilia
Psychiatric Journal of the University of Ottawa
Sources of confusion in the study and treatment of sadomasochism
Journal of Social Behavior and Personality
The sadistic murderer
Medicine, Science, and the Law
Sexual homicide: a motivational model
Journal of Interpersonal Violence
Rape trauma syndrome and post traumatic stress response
Rape: the price of coercive sexuality
The psychological aftermath of rape: long-term effects and individual differences in recovery
Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology
Sexual aggression: achieving power through humiliation
Detective magazines: pornography for the sexual sadist?
Journal of Forensic Science
The sexually sadistic criminal and his offenses
Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law
The killers among us: an examination of serial murder and its investigation
Sadism and masochism
Sadism and other paraphilias in normal controls and aggressive and nonaggressive sex offenders
Archives of Sexual Behavior
Adolescent sexual offenders: offender and offense characteristics
American Journal of Orthopsychiatry
Homicidal sex offenders: psychological, phallometric, and diagnostic
Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry & Law
The anatomy of human destructiveness
Antisocial personality disorder, sexual sadism, malignant narcissism, and serial murder
Journal of Forensic Sciences
The psychopathology of serial murder: a theory of violence
Offender and offense characteristics of sexual sadists: a comparative study
Journal of Forensic Sciences
Rape: the all-American crime
Men who rape: the psychology of the offender
Rape: power, anger, and sexuality
American Journal or Psychiatry
Sexual murder
British Journal of Psychiatry
Editorial: sexual sadism
Criminal Behavior and Mental Health
Cited by (87)
Hormonal response to perceived emotional distress in incarcerated men with sexual sadism
2022, Personality and Individual DifferencesCitation Excerpt :However, this categorical approach to sadism diagnosis is associated with low interrater reliability (Marshall & Kennedy, 2003; Marshall, Kennedy, & Yates, 2002). A growing body of literature also suggests that sadism is better understood as a dimension than a taxon (Longpre, Guay, Knight, & Benbouriche, 2018; Marshall & Kennedy, 2003; Mokros, Schilling, Weiss, Nitschke, & Eher, 2014). In the present study, we adopted this dimensional approach using the SeSaS as a unidimensional measure of sadism (Mokros, Schilling, Eher, & Nitschke, 2012).
Is paraphilic coercion a different construct from sadism or the lower end of an agonistic continuum?
2020, Journal of Criminal JusticeCitation Excerpt :The results of the present study also question the prevalent definitions of sadism that imply that it constitutes a distinct category. The poor reliability of sadism may not simply be a problem of poor diagnostic criteria (Marshall & Kennedy, 2003). Many of the DSM-5 diagnostic categories have not met even a relaxed level of acceptable interrater reliability (Regier et al., 2013), whereas these same disorders have often evidenced acceptable reliability when measured dimensionally (Markon, Chmielewski, & Miller, 2011).
Sadism: Review of an elusive construct
2019, Personality and Individual DifferencesCitation Excerpt :Sexual sadism is defined as sexual arousal in response to another person's suffering (Dietz, Hazelwood, & Warren, 1990; Eher et al., 2016; Hamilton & Rosen, 2016; MacCulloch et al., 1983; von Krafft-Ebing, 1886). Both psychological – particularly humiliation – and physical pain are mentioned in almost all definitions, although there is a lack of clarity as to whether psychological or physical pain are distinct motivations and whether one is more central to sexual sadism than the other (Longpré, Guay, & Knight, 2019; Marshall & Kennedy, 2003). There is also debate regarding whether the sadist's sexual arousal is elicited by the victim's pain per se or whether it comes from the accompanying power and control exerted over victims (Knoll & Hazelwood, 2009; MacCulloch et al., 1983; Proulx, Blais, & Beauregard, 2006).
Evaluation of Severe Sexual Sadism in a Forensic Population. French Validation of the Sexual Sadism Scale (SESAS)
2019, Annales Medico-PsychologiquesGAZING INTO THE ABYSS? MAKING SENSE OF EXTREME CRIME SCENE BEHAVIORS IN SEXUAL HOMICIDE
2024, Routledge Handbook of Homicide Studies