Table 1

Comparison of Regulatory/Monitoring Bodies

Monitoring AgencyCMSaTJCbDOJc
Investigation triggered by a Sentinel EventSometimesSometimesAlways
Routine and ongoing survey as part of conditions of participationYesYesNo
Compliance with federal regulatory standards for hospitalsSets and ensures compliance with conditions of participationMeets or exceeds CMS conditions of participation through establishment of elements of performanceEstablishes own standards
ParticipationVoluntaryVoluntaryInvoluntary
Effect of hospital’s certificationDeems hospital eligible to receive Medicare and Medicaid reimbursementsDeems hospital eligible to receive Medicare and Medicaid reimbursementsPrevents closure of hospital
Hospital ExpensesNo payment for regulationPays TJC a fee to be included in the survey processPays DOJ consultants for ongoing monitoring of process until compliance with settlement agreement is reached
Regulatory or survey processCollaborativeCollaborativeAdversarial
Attorneys as part of team of investigators/surveyorsNoNoYes
Investigation or survey based on court order or settlement agreementNoNoYes
Finite period of investigation or survey known at startYesYesYes
State and privately owned hospitals affectedYesYesNo (only state hospitals)
Survey initiated as a result of a complaintYesYesYes
  • aCMS: Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

  • bTJC: The Joint Commission.

  • cDOJ: Department of Justice.