Table 2

Variables in the Principal Diagnosis Groups

Independent VariablesNo Agreement n = 30Agree About Mental Disorder n = 65Agree on Principal Diagnosis n = 53p
Report writer factors
    Same expert status, n (%)16 (53)39 (69)30 (57)χ2=.40.82
    Same adversarial side, n (%)3 (10)24 (37)24 (45)χ2=10.87.004
    Same profession, n (%)21 (70)37 (57)32 (60)χ2=1.48.48
Plaintiff factors
    Male, n (%)18 (60)38 (58)27 (51)χ2=1.93.75
    Age, mean years (SD)38.9 (7.3)34.3 (7.0)32.6 (8.1)F=1.72.18
    IS score, median (IQR)12 (16)12 (21)12 (21)KW=.70.70
    Fatal accident, n (%)0 (0)16 (25)14 (26)χ2=9.62.008