Table 1

Criteria for Involuntary Admission

Date of PublicationDiagnoses Legally DefinedMedical Protective AdmissionEmergency Admission
Need to treatDanger to selfImpairment of judgmentRisk to selfRisk to othersRisk to society/public order
Shanghai2002Mental illnessYesNDLack of insightYesYesYes
Ningbo*2006Mental illnessYesNDCannot comprehend or control behavior
Hangzhou*2007Mental illnessYesNDCannot comprehend or control behavior
Beijing2007Severe mental illnessNDNDCannot comprehend mental health condition, perceive external reality, or control behaviorNoYesYes
Wuxi2007Severe mental illnessNDNDCannot comprehend mental health condition, perceive external reality, or control behaviorNoYesYes
Wuhan*2010Mental illnessYesNDCannot comprehend or control behavior
Shenzhen2012Mental illnessYesNDCannot comprehend or control behaviorYesYesYes
Draft 1Jun 2011Mental illnessNoYesCannot comprehend or control behaviorNoYesYes
Draft 2Oct 2001Severe mental illnessYesYesCannot comprehend mental health condition, perceive external reality, or manage personal affairsNoYesNo
National Law2012Severe mental illnessNoYesCannot comprehend mental health condition, perceive external reality, or manage personal affairsNoYesNo
  • ND, not defined.

  • * In Ningbo, Hangzhou, and Wuhan, there are no clear legal regulations for emergency admission. Mentally ill patients who are deemed a danger to others or society can only be detained if the dangerous behavior constitutes a criminal offense. In that situation, a compulsory admission is initiated by the police after a forensic psychiatric evaluation.